10 Best Bagel Toasters Reviewed 2024 and Buying Guide (With FAQs)

Sharing is caring!

Making a toast is an easy job. The struggle comes in when trying to shop for the best bagel toaster in the market. Different manufacturers produce toasters with unique features. While some stainless steel toasters toast four slices at once, other brands only have two slots. A good example is Hamilton Beach toaster with remarkable ability.

However, what should your preferred smart toaster be like? Is it necessary for a SMART toaster to have extra wide slots, lift ever, toaster ovens, keep warm, fits your kitchen counter space and perhaps made of stainless steel?

If you want to get the best stainless steel toaster oven with cord storage, that keeps warm, has a lift lever or a high lift for that matter, fits in your counter space and the rare lift and look feature, keep READING.

5 Bagel Toasters from amazon best seller list

What Is Bagel Toaster?

A bagel toaster is a setting present in some toasters that allows you to toast bagels. Unlike toasting bread, toasting a bagel only warms the surface as it toasts the cut surface. When toasting a bagel, the toaster lowers the power present in the outer heating elements.

Related Topic:

• How to toast a bagel without a toaster easily.
• Best bagel slicer reviews and buying tips.

10 Best Bagel Toasters Reviews

Here is a list of some of the quality toasters you can expect to get in the market:

1. OSTER 2 Slice Bread, Bagel Toaster, Metallic Grey

Oster Jelly 2 slice smart toaster is among quality toaster gadgets for perfectly crisp slices of toast. This toaster is manufactured using innovative technology with extra wide slots that is guaranteed to transform your kitchen experience.

Oster toaster comes with a dual bread guide. The guide has instructions on how to adjust the toaster to accommodate the number of slices. You can make different toasts including a bagel. You can also use it to keep warm your pieces of bread and bagels thanks to the bagel setting.

This toaster comes with a user-friendly control panel. It has an intuitive dial that allows you to adjust the toast shade or cancel toasting if need be. All this can be done with the press of a button.

Cleaning up the toasting mess just got easier. After toasting your bread or bagel, remove the crumb tray for easy cleaning. The high lift and anti-jamming mechanism is also present to prevent the toaster oven from jamming.

Oster toaster comes in an impressive design it has a timeless look that blends well with all kinds of kitchen decor. When you buy this toaster, you not only get a functional gadget but also a kitchen aesthetic.

Notable Features: 

• It weighs 3.9 pounds.
• Measures 11.7” by 6.9” by 7.3”.
• It has two slots: 115mm deep and 30mm wide.
• Features a defrost setting.
• It comes with a high-rise lever.

Pros

• Easy to use.
• Easy to clean.
• Smudge-proof.
• Anti-jamming.
• Cool to the touch.

Cons

• Sometimes toasts only one side.
• It does not toast evenly.

2. BLACK + DECKER T4569B 4-Slice Toaster, Bagel Toaster, Black

Black and Decker four-slice toaster comes ready for work! With just 6 pounds, this toaster is powered by 1400 watts making it one of the best bagel toasters. This toaster is ideal for big families because it can toast four slices of bread once. It also features self-adjusting slots.

Black Decker’s toaster comes with 6 different functions. You can toast your bread or bagel or even cancel. The control settings have 6 browning options to choose from, allowing you to toast your pieces of bread evenly.

If you want to toast only two slices of bread, you can do so without interfering with all of the slots. The dual control panel allows you to use only two slots independently. Instead of switching on all slot toasters, use the toaster oven you only need.

Safety is a priority when it comes to buying electrical appliances. During the manufacture of this toaster, Black Decker had your safety in mind. They designed the toaster to meet the safety standard set up by the North American electrical standards. You no longer need to worry about safety when you get this toaster.

Notable Features: 

• The smart toaster oven weighs 6 pounds.
• It has four slots.
• 6 browning functions.
• The smart toaster oven meets the North American electrical standards.
• Its dimensions are 10” by 11.5” by 7.6”
• Inbuilt bagel, frozen and cancel settings.

Pros

• Easy to clean.
• Easy to use.
• This slice smart toaster oven is durable.
• Cool to the touch.
• Ideal for big families.

Cons

• This toaster oven starts smoking after a few uses.
• The new model of this toaster oven does not toast evenly.

3. Holife Toaster 2 Slice, Stainless Steel Toaster

Holife toaster transforms your kitchen for the better. The two-slice toaster is made using stainless steel. The design used is impressive and easy on the eyes. It comes with modern features that make your toasting experience easier.

When you’re done toasting your bread or bagels, they will automatically pop up. The automatic pop-up feature makes it easy for you to take the bread out without struggling. In addition, you did not need to worry about your fingers getting burnt.

The digital countdown timer shows you the toasting process. It is well designed with a blue LCD screen that helps you keep track of the time. You can check up on the progress of your toast in a simple glance.

Toasted bread varies from light tan to dark tan. You can achieve the crunch type you like on your bread using the 6 toasting levels available. The lowest setting achieves lighter tans while the higher settings achieve darker toasts. When toasting thick slices of bread use the highest setting on the panel

Other amazing features that come in this Holife toaster are the toast boost and removable tray. Toast boost is a high-lift lever that brings your pastries high enough to get them from the toaster without burning your fingers. The removable tray collects all the breadcrumbs at the bottom of the toaster to facilitate easy cleaning.

Notable Features: 

• It weighs 3.4 pounds.
• The dimensions of the toaster are 12.7” by 7.9” by 8.2”
• It has a digital countdown timer.
• It has automatic pop-up settings.
• 6 toasting levels.
• Runs on 850 watts.

Pros

• Easy to use.
• Long-lasting.
• Ideal for bread and bagel.
• Stylish design.
• Value for money.

Cons

• It is flimsy.
• The heating elements are not well insulated.

4. Yabano 4 Slice Toaster 

Yabano 4 slice toaster comes in a compact design that allows you to defrost bagel or cancel. This three-in-one toaster is made of stainless steel and uses wattage of 1800 watts. The impressive design is suitable for all kitchen color schemes. When you get this toaster, it will blend well with your kitchen decor.

Yabano toaster comes with 7 different shade settings. You can brown your toast to your liking using any of the seven settings. If you love your toast lightly browned, use the lowest setting. For a crunchy dark toast use the highest settings.

This 3 IN 1 Toaster has 4 extra-wide slots. Having 1.6 inches wide slots allows you to cook different slices of bread such as waffles, bagels, or muffins. In addition to that, it comes with a removable warming rack made of stainless steel. You can also use it to serve the toast, muffin or croissant straight from your toaster.

The control panel is easy to use and offers different options. You can defrost, bagel, or cancel using the control panel settings.

Toasting bread can get messy. However, with this Yobana 4-slice toaster, you do not need to worry about a messy kitchen. It comes with removable trays that collect all the crumbs at the bottom of the toaster. This will make the cleaning work easier for you.

Notable Features: 

• It is made from stainless steel.
• Its dimensions are 13.9” by7.85” by 1 3.9”
• The toaster weighs 5.21 pounds.
• It comes with a removable warming rack.

Pros

• Great value for money.
• Easy to use.
• Easy to clean.
• Warmth settings.
• Removable tray.

Cons

• The toaster heats up when in use.
• One side of the toaster is slow.

5. Keenstone Toasters 2 Slice Retro Stainless 

Keenstone toaster comes ready to give the perfect breakfast experience! The retro toaster is made using stainless steel crafted into a beautiful design. The slots in this toaster are 1.5” wide to allow you toast all types of bread.

You can choose the setting you would like to use from the panel. The panel consists of three basic functions, cancel, bagel, and defrost. As for the toasting, there are 6 different toasting settings to help you make the perfect toast.

Ease of cleaning is guaranteed with the removable crumb tray. When you are done toasting, simply slide it out and clean it. Another amazing feature is the lift lever. When you finish toasting, the bread pops up. You can use the lift level to get small slices.

Notable Features: 

• Toaster comes with the bagel, defrost and cancel functions.
• Six levels of toasting.
• Removable crumb tray
• It weighs 4.05 pounds.
• Dimensions of the toaster are 11.42 inches by 7.09 inches by 7.28 inches.

Pros

• Premium material.
• Wide slot.
• Easy to clean
• Adjustable temperature control
• High accuracy.

Cons

• It heats up when in use.
• Sometimes it does not toast evenly.

6. Whall Toasters 2 Slice Best Rated Prime Bagel Toaster

Whall is a company that is known for manufacturing quality products and this bagel toaster is no exception. This model comes with 6 gear adjustments to accommodate everyone’s needs. Whether you love your toast lightly golden or dark toasted, this toaster allows you to make a toast that suits your preference.

This Whall toaster has four basic functions: defrost bagel, cancel, and toast. If you love to freeze your toast, this toaster will make things easier for you. You can also explore other pastries like bagels and English muffins. The cancel option enables you to stop the toaster midway if need be.

The 2- slice toaster is made using stainless steel. It has an impressive design that will suit your kitchen countertop. It also has wide slots measuring 1.5 inches. This feature enables you to experiment your kitchen prowess using different breads. It is suitable for thin waffles or thick breads.

When you use your toaster, bread slices are collected at the bottom. This toaster has a removable tray that makes work easier. After making your toast, simply pull out the tray and clean it up. However, you should allow the toaster to cool down before removing the tray.

It is important to note that the toaster might become hoe when in use.

Be cautious not to touch the hot surface with bare hands.

Notable Features: 

• It has four basic functions.
• Extra- wide slots.
• 4- Step operation.
• LED lights.
• Coil design for enhanced safety.
• Its dimensions are: 13.23” by 9.13” by 7.64”.

Pros

• Easy to clean.
• Easy to store.
• Wide slots.
• Even- browning.
• Great value for money.

Cons

• The toaster falls over when you push the buttons because it is lightweight.
• It has sharp edges.

7. Keenstone 2-Slice Retro Stainless Steel Toaster

If you are looking for the best toaster for bagels, Keenstone will be a good buy. Keenstone is a versatile toaster with three functions. The settings include bagel, defrost and cancel. You no longer need to look for a toaster that will suit your needs because Keenstone comes ready to change your cooking experience for the better.

We all love appliances that are made using premium quality material. Not only do they last long, but they also offer great value for money. The 2- slice toaster is built using stainless steel that is guaranteed to last for long. The design is also impressive to look at. You can choose a toaster that is in a color you like from the different colors available.

The extra wide toasting slots measure 1.5 inches. These slots allow you to toast thick slices of bread and other pastries. It also ensures that your bread is evenly toasted.

A lift lever enables you to lift your bread when it has toasted to your liking. Keenstone 2-slice toaster comes with the lift lever that allows you to lift the bread or pop it up automatically.

Therefore, you can use this toaster with small sizes of bread without worrying about getting burnt.

Note: Do not use this toaster to toast anything with jam, oil or water.

Notable Features: 

• Toaster is made from stainless steel.
• It weighs 4.05 pounds.
• Its dimensions are 11.42” by 7.09” by 7.28”.
• It comes with six settings for browning.
• Wattage capacity of 825 watts.

Pros

• Easy to use.
• Easy to clean.
• Durable.
• Lightweight.
• Value for money.

Cons

• It heats up while cooking.
• It burns toast after prolonged use.

8. Evening 2 Slice Best Prime Toaster

Evening 2 slice toaster is uniquely designed to fit your countertop without taking too much space. This toaster is made from food grade stainless steel so you can be assured of your safety. The premium stainless steel also features anti – overheat protection and is also rustproof.

If you like evenly toasted bread, this is the gadget for you. Seven shade settings are useful because they accommodate everyone’s taste. The lowest setting toasts bread to white while the darkest is puce. If you like golden – colored toast go for setting 3 or 4.

This toaster is user-friendly and easy to operate. The buttons are easy to use making it user- friendly. You can use the bagel, defrost and cancel controls to meet all your toasting demands hence saving your time.

Evening toaster one of the best bagel toasters you can buy. It features premium stainless steel that does not over heat. If you want to warm up your bagel or toast your bread in minutes, this will be a perfect choice.

Notable Features: 

• 7 shade settings.
• Wide toaster slots.
• 3 different controls.
• Removable crumb tray.
• It weighs 2.68 pounds.

Pros

• Lightweight.
• Easy to use.
• Easy to clean.
• Stylish design.
• Removable tray.

Cons

• Inconsistent temperature controls.
• It does not toast evenly.

9. Whall 4 Slice Toaster 1500W/ Black

You’ve probably heard the saying, breakfast is king. Whall four slice toaster model is the ultimate machine for a hearty family breakfast. This 1500-watt powered toaster model is a must-have for every home.

This four slice toaster model has 6-gear adjustments allow you to toast bread according to individual preference. Whether you like lightly golden brown or dark toast, this machine will toast bread to your liking. When toasting one slice, use low toast toasting. If you are toasting thick bread or several slices, use higher toast darkness setting.

The four slice toaster model features four wide slots are available in this toaster can be used to bake different slices of bread into golden brown. The amazing thing about this toaster is that it can make individual slices or more than one at a go. The independent control panels enable all these.

In addition, this four slice toaster model of bagel toaster has an indicator light display shows the three basic functions of this toaster, which include defrost, cancel and bagel. The model also comes with an impressive dashboard design and a removable tray.

Notable Features: 

• It weighs 6.32 pounds.
• Countdown timer.
• 4 extra wide slots & dual independent control.
• Bagel, defrost & cancel function.
• 4 toast settings.
• Powered by 1500 watts.

Pros

• Suitable for various breads.
• Ideal for big families.
• Easy to use.
• Removable crumb tray.
• Extra wide slots.

Cons

• On the first use, smell of burning rubber is evident.
• After prolonged use it does not toast evenly.

10. REDMOND Toaster 2 Slice Retro Bagel Toaster

Nothing beats a REDMOND that provides hot food and warm hearts. Redmond toaster comes in a stylish retro design that is a sight to behold. The glossy finish makes it an aesthetic that takes up minimal counter space. It is made from premium quality stainless steel guaranteed to last you for years.

This toaster is powered by 800 watts making it powerful. In addition, it has an anti-sticking function that makes toasting work more convenient. When the pastry gets stuck, you can remove it from the toaster manually or automatically power it off. The toaster initiates automatic power off function when the furnace temperatures are too high to prevent the machine from burning. If you want to manual stop, press the cancel button.

There are three different functions this toaster performs: defrost, cancel and bagel. Bagel function bakes bagels on one side while defrost function thaws frozen breads. As for the cancel function, it stops all toasting operations.

How do you like your toast? I like mine slightly browned. Whether you like a light browned toast or a darker one, you can be able to achieve that with the 7 browning settings. Redmond toaster comes with 7 in-built browning setting to fit all your toasting needs.

Some other amazing features include the cord wrap storage and high lift lever. At the bottom of the toaster, there is a storage space to store the power cord. This provision makes you kitchen neat as it conceals the 89cm long chord. You can take out your small slices of bread using the high lift.

Notable Features: 

• It weighs 3.41 pounds.
• Measures 13” by 7.4” by 7.8”.
• Powered by 800 watts.
• 3 different functions.
• 7 browning levels.
• Countdown timer.
• Removable crumb tray.

Pros

• High grade sheerness.
• Easy to use.
• Easy to clean.
• Value for money.
• Retro design.

Cons

• Toaster gets hot when in use.
• Crumb tray is small.

Factors to Consider When Buying a Bagel Toaster

As we all know, breakfast is the most important meal of the day. That is why you need to have the top- rated bagel toaster in your kitchen for the perfect breakfasts that charge up your day. With the different brands of toasters available in the market, choosing the excellent bagel toaster can be overwhelming! The good news is, we are going to list some factors you should look for to help you narrow down your choices.

Read on to understand the factors you should consider before buying a toaster.

Size :

The most important factor to consider before buying a toaster is the size. The size of a toaster is determined by the counter space available, how big the slots are, and the number of slices to toast at a go.

The space you are willing to allocate your new toaster will determine the type of toaster you buy. If you have limited counter space, go for a toaster that does not take up much space. 2-slice toasters are ideal for mall spaces. If you have plenty of room to spare, getting a 4-slice toaster is a welcome idea. You can also opt for countertop toaster ovens if your space allows it.

Slots in toasters vary depending on the brand. Most of the pop-up toasters have wide slots compared to the regular toasters. The normal toaster has a slot that is big enough to fit a standard slice of bread. Toasters with bigger slots can toast other pastries like bagels and English muffins.

The last question you need to ask yourself about the size of a toaster is the number of slices to toast at a go. If you have a big family, you will need to buy the 4-slice toaster because it toasts many slices at once.

Cost:

The cost of a toaster depends on the type and brand. Counter-top toaster ovens tend to be pricier than conventional pop-up toasters. Manufacturers use different materials to make toasters thus the difference in prices.

Some toasters tend to be cheaper than others because they are built using cheap materials that make toasts just fine even though they are not durable. On the other hand, some models have premium features that make them more expensive than their competitors.

You should choose a toaster that is made of premium material that is guaranteed to serve you for a long time. However, you should also compare different brands to get the best buy that is in line with your budget.

Durability:

Everybody wants to buy a toaster that will serve them well for a couple of years before replacing it. How do you know the durability span of a toaster? There are many reviews available for you to check out before buying a toaster.

You should also consider the type of material used to make the appliance. Be sure to go for one that is strong and can withstand daily use. Conduct your due diligence before making buying the best bagel toaster.

Ease Of Use And Cleaning

Toasters are usually easy to operate after the first few trial and errors that help you familiarize yourself with the appliance. You should look for a toaster that has settings that are easy to follow. Some toasters have knob settings while others have buttons. Make sure you look for a toaster that will simplify your toasting experience.

The ease of cleaning should not be overlooked when shopping for a toaster. Toasting bread, bagels, or muffins can get a little bit messy. Therefore, you should consider a toaster that has removable trays.

Removable crumb trays are a lifesaver when it comes to cleaning your toaster. After you are done making your delicious toasts, simply remove the tray for easy cleaning. It also helps to buy a toaster with non-stick interiors to avoid complications during cleaning.

Settings:

Simple toasters come with three settings that allow you to toast your bread slices either medium, or dark. While these are the basic settings on every toaster, some models go ahead and include a wider range of settings.

Sophisticated models may have up to seven browning levels. In other models, you may find additional settings like the bagel, defrost, and cancel options.

If you freeze your toast, having a defrosting button will come in handy. A toaster with many presets will simplify your cooking experience.

Uses

How do you intend to use your toaster? If you have simple needs like toasting using standard slices of bread, you should go for a simple toaster. You can choose just about any toaster because it will get the job done.

However, if you want to use your toaster for different purposes in your kitchen, you might need to buy one that allows for different types of pastries. You should be on the lookout for a toaster that has big slots to accommodate items other than bread slices

Tips on Bagel toasters (With FAQs)

Q: What is the best toaster on the market?

Answer: 

A: The best toaster on the market is the OSTER 2-Slice bread bagel toaster. It comes with a dual bread guide, intuitive dial, and removable crumb trays. In addition, it comes with a high-rise lever to bring up your pastries when they are done cooking.

Q: Can you put a bagel in the toaster?

Answer: 

A: Most of the toasters have a bagel setting that only toasts the facing side. If your toaster does not have these settings, you can still use it to toast your bagels. A maximum of five minutes is recommended.

Q: Can I toast a bagel in a toaster?

Answer: 

A: You can toast a bagel in a toaster if you want to restore it. Simply slice it up and toast it. If you want to toast a dry bagel, you should put it in the toaster while it is intact. Leave it in the toaster or oven preheated to 375 degrees for five minutes.

Q: What is the best toaster to buy?

Answer: 

A: The best toaster to buy is the Yabano 4-slice toaster. This toaster has wide slots and it can toast 4 slices at once. It comes with a removable warming tray that allows you to server straight from the toaster. Other additional functions include 7 browning settings, easy to use control panel, and a sleek stainless steel design.

Q: What does the bagel button do?

Answer: 

A: The bagel button is a setting used to toast bagels or English muffins. Bagels and English muffins take longer to cook than the regular bread. When you select this option, the toaster adjusts toasting time.

Q: Which is the best way to put a bagel in the toaster?

Answer: 

A: Making bagels in a toaster is a no-brainer. Insert the rack in the middle and place your bagel at the center rack or bottom rack. The sides should be facing up. Lock the door and wait for 4 minutes until done.

Q: How can you toast bagels for a crowd?

Answer: 

A: Use an oven preheated at 177 degrees Celsius. Place the bagels on a baking sheet and bake for five minutes. Flip and heat for an additional 5 minutes. If you prefer crunchy bagels, heat every side for 8 to 10 minutes.

Video: You’ve Been Using Your Toaster All Wrong?

Conclusion

I bet you love sandwich bread. The only way you’ll enjoy your bread brown is by investing in any of the bagel toasters reviewed herein. The best bagel toaster for sandwich bread should be within your budget, has a bagel button, cuts slices of bread to the size you want, and has a removable crumb among other notable things. Knowing the intended use of your toaster will make it easy for you to choose one that will suit your needs during home cook.

In this article, we have discussed some of the best toasters available in the market. We have also made it easy for you to choose the best toaster with bagel buttons, blue led indicator, breville die cast, several control panels, and extra wide slots among others.