If you love sipping whiskey on the rocks, you already know a standard ice cube melts way too fast and waters down your drink. Large ice cubes are the answer—they melt slowly, chill your bourbon or scotch perfectly, and look great in a glass. But not all big ice cube trays are created equal. Some are flimsy, hard to pop out, or leak. I’ve tested dozens to find the best large ice cube tray for whiskey that actually delivers. Whether you want slow-melting cubes, easy release, or a great value, this list has you covered.
Quick Product Comparison
Our Top 10 Best Large Ice Cube Tray For Whiskey Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
1. Bangp 2-Pack Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey – 16 Big Cubes, Easy Release Square Mold for Cocktails
This Bangp set comes with two trays and two clear lids, so you can make 16 large cubes at once. The size is perfect for a standard rocks glass, and the silicone material makes popping out cubes effortless.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ 2 trays, 2 lids – 16 cubes total
- ✓ Tight-fitting lid prevents freezer odors
- ✓ Flexible silicone for easy release
- ✓ Each cube is about 2 inches square
Why We Recommend It
If you want a no-fuss system that delivers consistent large cubes every time, this is it. The lids lock in freshness, and the trays stack neatly in your freezer. Bangp hits the sweet spot between value and performance.
Best For
Whiskey lovers who want plenty of slow-melting cubes without breaking the bank. Great for parties or daily use.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Very easy to remove cubes
- Lids keep ice clean
- Durable and BPA-free
- Good value for a 2-pack
Cons:
- Lids can be a bit tight initially
- Some users wish cubes were slightly larger
Customer Reviews
“Customer Review: I’ve been using these for a month and they work great. The lids are a game changer – no more weird freezer taste on my ice. Cubes pop out easily and are the perfect size for my bourbon.” – Mark T.
“Customer Review: Good trays for the price. I like that they come with lids. Only minor issue is that the lid can be tricky to snap on, but once you get the hang of it, it’s fine.” – Sarah J.
2. GGOW Large Silicone Ice Cube Trays 2 Inch – Huge Square Cubes for Whisky and Cocktails
GGOW’s tray features an internal steel frame that keeps the tray rigid, even when full of water. The upgraded bottom has individual compartments so you can remove just one cube at a time without disturbing the rest.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Steel frame for no-leak stability
- ✓ Individual compartments for one-at-a-time release
- ✓ Comes with a silicone lid
- ✓ Freezes in 6-8 hours
Why We Recommend It
The steel frame is a standout – no more trays bending and spilling water in the freezer. The ice cubes are perfectly clear and slow-melting. This is our editor’s choice because it combines durability with thoughtful design.
Best For
Anyone who hates dealing with flimsy trays. The steel frame makes this a long-lasting investment for serious home bartenders.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Rigid frame prevents spills
- Easy to remove single cubes
- Clear ice results with proper method
- BPA-free and food-grade silicone
Cons:
- Price is higher than basic trays
- Only 6 cubes per tray
Customer Reviews
“Customer Review: This is my second set of GGOW trays. The steel frame makes a huge difference. No more water sloshing around. Cubes come out perfectly clear if you use distilled water. Highly recommend.” – David L.
“Customer Review: Great quality tray. The lid seals well and the ice releases easily. I wish it made more cubes at once, but the quality makes up for it.” – Emma R.
3. Ice Cube Molds 2-Pack – 8 Large Square Cubes, Slow-Melt Ice for Whiskey, Cocktails, Coffee & More
This budget-friendly 2-pack creates eight jumbo cubes (just under 2 inches each) that melt slowly. The flexible silicone design makes it easy to pop cubes out, and you can use them for cocktails, iced coffee, or even popsicles.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ 8 large cubes per batch (2-pack total 16)
- ✓ Flexible non-stick silicone
- ✓ Ideal for cocktails, coffee, and infused ice
- ✓ BPA-free and dishwasher safe
Why We Recommend It
You don’t need to spend a lot to get great large ice cubes. This set is affordable, works perfectly, and the silicone is thick enough to last. It’s our top pick if you’re trying big ice for the first time.
Best For
Whiskey drinkers on a budget or anyone who wants an inexpensive way to upgrade their home bar. Also great for iced coffee.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Very affordable
- Cubes release easily
- Multi-purpose use
- Compact storage
Cons:
- No lid included
- Some report slight silicone smell initially
Customer Reviews
“Customer Review: For the price, you can’t beat these. Cubes are huge and last a long time. I use them for whiskey and iced coffee. Only thing missing is a lid, but I just wrap them in plastic wrap.” – James P.
“Customer Review: Good basic trays. The cubes are around 1.8 inches, which is fine. They do absorb a bit of freezer smell, so I’d recommend covering them.” – Laura M.
4. FDDBI 2-Pack Ice Cube Tray with Lid – Big Square Old Fashioned Maker for Cocktail and Whisky
FDDBI’s 2-pack includes lids and produces 12 square cubes (2 inches each). The independent cavities mean each cube comes out cleanly without breaking. The silicone lid seals securely to protect from freezer burn.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ 12 large cubes total (6 per tray)
- ✓ Individual cavities for clean release
- ✓ Tight-fitting silicone lid included
- ✓ BPA-free and flexible
Why We Recommend It
If you want a reliable set with lids that actually stay on, this is a solid choice. The cubes are a nice size for old fashioned or any rocks drink. It’s a straightforward no-frills tray that does the job well.
Best For
People who want a complete set with lids at a reasonable price. Good for everyday use and small parties.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Lids fit snugly
- Easy to remove cubes
- Decent size cubes
- Value for 2-pack
Cons:
- Silicone can be a bit sticky at first
- Not stackable without a flat surface
Customer Reviews
“Customer Review: I like that these come with lids – keeps the ice from tasting like leftover pizza. Cubes are big and work great for my evening scotch. Would buy again.” – Tom B.
“Customer Review: Good trays. The silicone is flexible enough to pop cubes out easily. My only complaint is that the lid can be a little hard to put on, but it does seal well.” – Anna K.
5. VLM 3-Pack Ice Cube Molds with Stackable Lid – Square Tray for Whiskey, Cocktails, Bourbon & Soups
VLM’s 3-pack is perfect if you entertain often. Each tray holds 6 cubes, giving you 18 cubes at once. The internal frame provides stability, and a handle makes carrying from sink to freezer easy.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ 3 trays – 18 cubes per batch
- ✓ Internal sturdy frame with handle
- ✓ Stackable lid included
- ✓ Flexible silicone for easy release
Why We Recommend It
This set is a powerhouse for parties. You’ll never run out of ice. The handle is a thoughtful touch, and the stackable lids keep everything organized. Great value for the quantity.
Best For
Households that go through ice quickly. Perfect for bourbon tastings, cocktail parties, or just having backup cubes.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- High capacity – 18 cubes
- Stable frame with handle
- Lids allow stacking
- Affordable per tray
Cons:
- Frame can be slightly noisy
- Lids may not be 100% airtight
Customer Reviews
“Customer Review: Love having 3 trays! I make a batch and have enough for the whole weekend. The handle makes it easy to carry. Cubes are a good size and release easily.” – Chris W.
“Customer Review: Good product for the price. The frame helps keep the shape. One of the lids was a bit warped, but still works fine. Overall happy.” – Megan S.
6. Samuelworld 2-Pack Silicone Ice Trays – 2-Inch Cubes & 2.5-Inch Sphere Molds, BPA-Free for Whiskey, Cocktails
This combo pack gives you both large cubes and spherical ice balls. The 2-inch cube tray makes 6 cubes, and the sphere tray makes 4 large balls. The integrated funnel system on the sphere mold helps fill without mess.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ 2-in-1: cubes and spheres
- ✓ Funnel fill for spheres
- ✓ BPA-free silicone
- ✓ Perfect for variety
Why We Recommend It
If you like to switch between cubes and spheres, this set offers the best of both worlds. The sphere mold produces clear ice balls that look stunning in a tumbler. Samuelworld is a trusted brand for ice molds.
Best For
Home bartenders who want flexibility. Great for making fancy cocktails with sphere ice or classic large cubes.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Two shapes in one purchase
- Spheres are large and clear
- Easy to fill and release
- Good quality silicone
Cons:
- Sphere tray only makes 4 at a time
- No lids included
Customer Reviews
“Customer Review: Love the variety. The sphere ice is perfect for my bourbon and looks awesome. Cubes are also great. No lids, but I just lay plastic wrap on top. Highly recommend.” – Nick D.
“Customer Review: Fun set. The sphere mold takes a bit of practice to get clear ice, but it works well. The cube tray is straightforward. Good value for two different types.” – Rachel H.
7. Samuelworld 2-Pack Ice Cube Molds – 2-Inch Cubes, 8 Cavity Easy Release for Whiskey, Cocktails & Gifts
This classic Samuelworld 2-pack produces 16 large cubes (2 inches each). The 8-cavity design is tried and true. Silicone is thick and durable, and the cubes release with a simple twist.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ 16 cubes from 2 trays
- ✓ 2-inch square cubes
- ✓ High-quality, thick silicone
- ✓ BPA-free and easy to clean
Why We Recommend It
Samuelworld is a known name in ice molds, and this 2-pack delivers reliable performance. The cubes are consistently shaped and slow-melting. It’s a straightforward choice that won’t disappoint.
Best For
Whiskey purists who want simple, effective trays without extra frills. Also makes a great gift.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Proven design
- Durable silicone
- Even freezing
- Good size cubes
Cons:
- No lids
- Can be tough to stack in freezer
Customer Reviews
“Customer Review: I’ve had these for over a year and they still look new. Cubes are perfect for my old fashioned. No complaints at all.” – Steve R.
“Customer Review: These molds are sturdy and the cubes come out easily. I wish they came with lids to prevent freezer taste, but otherwise great.” – Karen L.
8. 2-Pack Whiskey Ice Cube Trays – Silicone Molds with Steel Frame & Lid, 2-Inch Cubes for Cocktails
These trays combine a steel frame for rigidity with a clear silicone lid that seals each compartment individually. The non-stick silicone ensures cubes release cleanly, and the lid prevents spills during transport.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Steel frame for stability
- ✓ Individual sealing lid
- ✓ Non-stick silicone
- ✓ 2-inch cubes
Why We Recommend It
The spill-proof lid is a standout feature – fill the tray, snap on the lid, and carry it without a drip. The steel frame means no bending or cracking. A well-engineered product for hassle-free ice making.
Best For
People who want maximum convenience and zero mess. Ideal for those who transport trays to the freezer with water already in them.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Spill-proof lid
- Sturdy construction
- Easy release
- Good value for 2-pack
Cons:
- Lid can be tricky to align at first
- Slightly heavier than all-silicone trays
Customer Reviews
“Customer Review: The steel frame makes these feel premium. The lid seals tightly – I’ve never had a spill. Cubes pop out perfectly. Highly recommend for everyday use.” – Mike C.
“Customer Review: Great trays! The lids are a game changer for keeping ice fresh. Only minor issue is that the lid is a bit stiff initially, but it loosens up.” – Sarah W.
9. GGOW Large Silicone Ice Cube Trays 2-Inch – Huge Square Ice Cubes for Whisky and Cocktail
This GGOW tray (similar to #2 but single-pack) also features an internal steel frame and individual bottom compartments. It makes 6 large cubes and comes with a silicone lid. The design minimizes freezer burn.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Steel frame for no-sag design
- ✓ Individual compartments
- ✓ Lid included
- ✓ 6 cubes per tray
Why We Recommend It
If you prefer a single tray option, this GGOW is a great choice. The steel frame is durable, and the cubes are consistently clear (use distilled water). It’s a bit pricier than basic trays but built to last.
Best For
Those who want one high-quality tray rather than a multi-pack. Perfect for small households.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Excellent build quality
- Clear ice results
- Easy to remove single cubes
- Sturdy and leak-proof
Cons:
- Only 6 cubes per tray
- More expensive than standard trays
Customer Reviews
“Customer Review: Best ice cube tray I’ve ever used. The steel frame is fantastic – no more spills. The ice is crystal clear and melts slowly. Worth every penny.” – John M.
“Customer Review: I bought this for my husband who loves whiskey. He says the ice is perfect. The tray is easy to clean and the lid keeps the ice fresh. Would recommend.” – Lisa G.
10. ROTTAY 2-Pack Ice Cube Trays – Sphere Ice Ball & Large Square Makers for Whiskey, Cocktails
ROTTAY’s 2-pack includes a sphere tray (6 balls) and a square tray (6 large cubes). The sphere tray has an upgraded quick-open buckle for easy release. Both are made from premium silicone that’s freezer and dishwasher safe.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ 6 spheres and 6 cubes per batch
- ✓ Quick-open buckle on sphere tray
- ✓ Premium silicone, dishwasher safe
- ✓ BPA-free and flexible
Why We Recommend It
This set offers great variety for cocktail enthusiasts. The sphere tray’s buckle makes releasing ice balls effortless. The cubes are also 2 inches and slow-melting. A fun and functional addition to any home bar.
Best For
Those who enjoy both sphere and cube ice. Great for making visually appealing drinks.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Two shapes in one pack
- Easy release buckle
- Durable material
- Good capacity
Cons:
- No lids included
- Sphere size is 2 inches, not standard 2.5
Customer Reviews
“Customer Review: I love this set! The buckle on the sphere tray is genius – no more struggling to get the ice out. Both trays work great. Highly recommend for anyone who likes variety.” – Alex F.
“Customer Review: Good quality trays. The spheres are a bit smaller than I expected, but they still look nice in a glass. Easy to clean and no weird smells.” – Julie B.
Complete Buying Guide for Best Large Ice Cube Tray For Whiskey
Essential Factors We Consider
When choosing the best large ice cube tray for whiskey, material is key. Silicone trays are flexible and easy to pop out, but some bend and spill. Look for trays with a steel frame or thicker silicone for stability. Size matters too – a 2-inch cube melts slowly without overcrowding your glass. Lids are a bonus: they keep your ice from absorbing freezer odors. Also consider the number of cavities: a 6-cube tray is standard, but 8 or 10 gives you more ice at once. Don’t forget about BPA-free certification and dishwasher safety for easy cleaning.
Budget Planning
You don’t need to spend a fortune. Basic silicone 2-packs can be under $15 and work well. Mid-range options with steel frames or silicone lids range from $20 to $30. Premium sets with multiple shapes or patented designs can go up to $40. For everyday use, a mid-range tray like the GGOW or FDDBI offers the best balance of cost and performance. If you entertain often, investing in a 3-pack like VLM gives you plenty of ice for parties.
Final Thoughts
A large ice cube tray is a simple upgrade that improves your whiskey experience. Slow-melting ice keeps your drink cold without diluting it quickly. We recommend starting with a 2-pack with lids to keep ice fresh. If you want the best of both worlds, a cube-and-sphere combo adds variety. No matter your budget, there’s a great option here. For more kitchen essentials, check out our guide on the best ice cubes for drinks that don’t melt to further enhance your drink experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Why use large ice cubes for whiskey?
A: Large ice cubes melt slower than small cubes, so they chill your drink without watering it down as quickly. This preserves the flavor of the whiskey while keeping it cold.
Q: Are silicone ice cube trays better than plastic?
A: Yes, silicone is more flexible, making it easier to release cubes. It’s also BPA-free and more durable. Plastic trays can crack and are harder to pop out cubes from.
Q: How do I make clear ice cubes at home?
A: Use distilled water and a directional freezing method. Some trays, like the GGOW, are designed to help produce clearer ice. You can also boil water twice before freezing to remove air bubbles.
Q: Can I use these trays for other liquids?
A: Absolutely! You can freeze juice, coffee, broth, or even fruit-infused water to add flavor to cocktails or iced drinks. Just make sure the tray is silicone and flexible enough for easy release.
Q: How many cubes do I need for a party?
A: For a party of 8-10, a 3-pack tray (like VLM) producing 18 cubes per batch is a good start. You can also make cubes in advance and store them in a freezer bag. Pair your setup with a best countertop ice maker with water line if you need a constant supply.
Conclusion
Choosing the best large ice cube tray for whiskey comes down to your priorities: budget, capacity, or premium features. The Bangp 2-pack is our top overall pick for its value and lids. If you want a sturdy steel-frame tray, the GGOW editor’s choice is unbeatable. For budget buyers, the Ice Cube Molds 2-pack delivers quality at a low price. No matter which you pick, you’ll enjoy slower-melting ice and a better drinking experience. Also, keep your ice maker water clean with a best inline water filter for ice maker to ensure the purest taste. Ready to upgrade your home bar? Click any “Check Price” button above to get your tray today!
