Looking for a reliable side-by-side refrigerator without an ice maker? You’re in the right place. Whether you’re upgrading your kitchen, moving into a new home, or just want more control over your water and ice needs, choosing the best side-by-side refrigerator without an ice maker can save you money on maintenance while still offering ample storage. These models are perfect for those who prefer manual ice trays or external dispensers, giving you flexibility without sacrificing style or efficiency.
Quick Product Comparison
Our Top 10 Best Side By Side Without Ice Maker Reviews – Expert Tested & Recommended
1. SPECILITE Compact Countertop Ice Maker, Self-Cleaning, 26L/24H, 9 Cubes in 6–8 Mins, Portable with Accessories (Black)
★★★★☆ 4.2/5
This compact countertop ice maker delivers fast, reliable performance with minimal noise. Ideal for small kitchens or offices, it produces up to 26 pounds of ice daily and features a self-cleaning function for easy maintenance. Its sleek black design blends seamlessly into modern spaces.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Makes 9 ice cubes in just 6–8 minutes
- ✓ Self-cleaning mode for hygienic operation
- ✓ Quiet cooling system ideal for home use
- ✓ Includes scoop, basket, and funnel accessories
- ✓ Compact size fits easily on countertops
Why We Recommend It
This model stands out for its balance of speed, quiet operation, and user-friendly design. The self-cleaning feature ensures long-term reliability without extra effort, making it a top pick for daily use.
Best For
Small households, dorm rooms, offices, or anyone who values quick access to fresh ice without the bulk of built-in systems.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Fast ice production—ready in under 10 minutes
- Quiet operation won’t disturb conversations
- Includes useful accessories like a scoop and funnel
- Self-cleaning reduces maintenance hassle
Cons:
- Water reservoir requires frequent refilling for heavy users
- Limited capacity compared to larger units
- Some users report minor issues after extended use
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Works as expected., 2 weeks in. The larger size ‘bullet’ shaped cubes work well to ice down a drink. If you make several batches at once, utilizing the full water capacity, some on the bottom will melt and refreeze into a mass. Easily solved with an ice mallet to break it up.”
Customer Review: “Update #2: Today it broke, I had it less than a year and the piece that moves the ice into the bucket broke on one side. It won’t fully clear now, it always thinks the ice is full and won’t make any more ice until I clear it. I will be buying a different machine soon.Update: I’ve had the machine for about seven weeks now, I still love it, but it is only making the large ice pieces. We have turned it off and reset it to the small setting but still only get the larger pieces.Good little machine, received it in a Friday evening and by Sunday morning I had a full bag of ice. It’s very quiet, you hardly hear it filling or dumping. I use filtered water in it since water out of my tap doesn’t taste good, and the ice has no taste unlike the ice out of my freezer’s ice maker.”
2. Iceman Dual-Size Countertop Ice Maker, 26L/24H, 1.3 lb Ice, Self-Cleaning, Stainless-Steel
★★★★★ 4.5/5
This dual-size ice maker offers unmatched versatility with the ability to produce both large and small bullet-shaped cubes. With stainless steel construction and a self-cleaning cycle, it combines durability with convenience for everyday use.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Choose between big or small ice cubes
- ✓ Produces 9 pieces in just 6 minutes
- ✓ Sleek stainless steel exterior resists fingerprints
- ✓ Self-cleaning function keeps the unit hygienic
- ✓ Quiet operation suitable for home environments
Why We Recommend It
The dual-size capability sets this model apart from competitors, allowing customization based on beverage type. Combined with fast production and a stylish build, it’s ideal for entertaining or personal use.
Best For
Home bars, parties, or anyone who enjoys different ice textures—from slow-melting bullets for cocktails to smaller cubes for sodas.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Dual-size output increases versatility
- Stainless steel design looks premium
- Very quiet during operation
- Easy-to-use controls and cleaning process
Cons:
- No magnetic scoop holder included
- Requires purified water for best results
- Slightly higher price point than basic models
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “I’ve only had this for a couple weeks, and so far nothing negative. This machine rocks as follows:-Love the stainless steel, sleek design. Matches everything in my kitchen. Machine is taller than I realized, so be sure you’ve factored in spacing required for going under cabinets in kitchen, or put in open space with nothing above it. Mine fits comfortably under a cabinet.-Performs as expected. Inside stays clean. We use purified water only for ice cubes, which reduces and even eliminates staining. No smell inside or out.-Super easy to start and stop. You’re only going to be using the start and select buttons. That’s it. Easy to clean and wipe down. Water resistant.-Not super loud. Pretty minimal IMO.-Creates ice pretty quick but allow it to go through several cycles of you want more ice.-To prevent ice from melting once dispensed in basket, I scoop it out immediately and put it in a Ziploc freezer bag. Each time ice is dispensed I do it again. Pull the bag out of the freezer and repeat process…scoop ice in, seal and put back in freezer. This way we have a whole gallon size bag full of ice in the freezer ready to be used that same day or next day. This does mean you’d have to be on standby, but I love doing it this way. Ice generally doesn’t freeze together either making it difficult to break apart once in freezer. When I put the full bag of ice in my freezer, I lay it flat so there’s no ice clumps. Easy peasy.The only negative thing IMO is that this product doesn’t come with a magnetic strip or fixture of some kind to be able to keep the white scoop stored on the side when not in use. Not a deal breaker, though…my husband and I plan on investing in one just to keep the scooper off the counter. I usually sit it on top of the machine where the window is. Still a 5 star product.”
Customer Review: “This is our 3rd ice machine and so far the best! No louder than the other ones but works the best so far! And the nugget ice is the bomb and self cleaning worked great! Worth every penny! So far we are VERY happy customers. Iceman won my business!”
3. Frigidaire EFIC103-AMZ-SC Countertop Ice Maker, Over-Sized Bucket, Self-Cleaning, Stainless Steel
★★★★☆ 4.1/5
A budget-friendly option that doesn’t compromise on performance. This Frigidaire model offers large-capacity ice production with a spacious over-sized bucket and self-cleaning functionality, all wrapped in a durable stainless steel shell.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Produces up to 26 pounds of ice per day
- ✓ Makes ice in under 6 minutes per batch
- ✓ Over-sized ice basket holds up to 2.2 lbs at once
- ✓ Self-cleaning mode for easy maintenance
- ✓ Compact footprint fits most countertops
Why We Recommend It
For the price, this unit delivers impressive output and reliability. Its large ice basket means fewer interruptions, and the self-cleaning feature ensures consistent hygiene without added effort.
Best For
Budget-conscious buyers who still want dependable daily ice production without breaking the bank.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Affordable yet powerful performance
- Large ice storage reduces refill frequency
- Quiet compared to older models
- Stainless steel finish resists corrosion
Cons:
- Only produces one cube size (not customizable)
- Instructions could be clearer for first-time users
- Bucket fills up quickly during heavy use
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “My husband was tired of travelling to the store every two or three days to buy me ice. Not just any ice at any store, it had to be a certain ice. Bless him, I have the best husband. I drink lots of ice water and love to chew on the ice. Our new home came with a fancy fridge with a built in ice maker/crusher that we don’t use anymore. The ice is too hard, and when you use the crushing option, it provides you with smaller chunks of razor like ice shards. Needless to say we don’t even have it hooked up anymore. The ice I prefer is round with a hole in the center. I’m not sure how or why, but it produces a softer less deadly, chewable ice. I’m not a huge fan of the snow cone type ice as it melts too fast and even from the start there is really nothing to chew. So my husband figured he spends close to $400 a year on ice. This does not include transportation to and from the store. I found this ice maker online and he said ‘GET IT!!’ I purchased it and told him not to get his hopes up because if I didn’t like the ice it produces, it’s going back. Well that isn’t the case. I LOVE the ice, it’s smaller and even softer than the ice we had been purchasing from the store. It also has the hole in the center of the cube, which makes me wonder if that is the key to soft chewable ice. The unit is fairly quiet. In fact it’s much quieter that the refrigerator ice maker. I think it’s because it has less of an ice drop to create that earth shattering noise. It works really fast. I’ve only made the large cubes, which are still fairly small, and it will produce them in about 10 minutes. It drops enough to fill a small glass, but in 10 more minutes you have more. We hooked it up, left the house for 2 hours and came home to a full bin of ice. I emptied into a large 2 gallon ziploc freezer bag. It took about 4 full bins to fill that bag up. When the ice enters the ziploc it’s a little wet, so it tends to refreeze in the freezer and make a solid chunk. This chunk easily separates with one hard drop of the bag onto the counter, so this is not an issue at all. The 2 gallon bag takes up a lot less space in the freezer than the 20lb bag we had previously been buying. I primarily take from the counter top unit when I fill my glass and save my ziploc as a backup. The rest of the family uses a lot of ice and the unit does well to meet our demand. My only complaints (and they are by no means deal breakers) are that the counter unit is much larger than I was expecting. I wish it took up less space on the counter AND for being so large, the bin that holds the ice is rather small and fills up quickly. That’s all.. Otherwise, I love it. So happy to have found it.”
Customer Review: “The product description and some photos in the listing are not accurate, this does not make 3 sizes. It only makes one size cube. That said, this is a nice unit. Set up is easy. Pour in water to the fill line, put in the basket and press the start button. It makes ice until the basket is full. When you un-box, take off all the shipping tape holding the inside basket and the ice ejector flap. There is a hidden piece of tape holding the ice ejector flap in place for shipping – it needs to be removed. The ice basket was totally full after about 75 minutes. One basket of ice fills a 1 quart Chinese restaurant soup container to put ice in the freezer for storage. It is fairly compact – 11 inches high, 10 inches deep and 9 inches wide. The machine is pretty quiet, there is a low intermittent fan sound when it is running. The instructions say to have some free space around the unit for air intake and discharge. I am impressed with it.”
4. COMMODORE Bullet Ice Maker, 28 lbs/Day, Compact, Self-Cleaning, Scooper Included
★★★★☆ 4.6/5
This compact bullet ice maker delivers high output with a sleek design and includes a convenient scoop. Capable of producing up to 28 pounds daily, it’s perfect for small homes, offices, or recreational vehicles needing reliable ice on demand.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Produces bullet-shaped ice in 6 minutes
- ✓ Up to 28 lbs of ice per day
- ✓ Built-in handle for easy portability
- ✓ Includes ice scoop for mess-free handling
- ✓ Self-cleaning mode for hygiene
Why We Recommend It
With its rugged build and efficient cooling system, this unit handles heavy use without skipping a beat. The included scoop adds value, and the self-cleaning function ensures long-term usability.
Best For
RVs, boats, small apartments, or anyone needing portable, consistent ice without a permanent installation.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- High daily output meets busy schedules
- Compact and lightweight for easy transport
- Includes practical accessories like a scoop
- Quiet operation minimizes disruption
Cons:
- Loud fan noise during operation
- Small water reservoir requires frequent refills
- No magnetic storage for the scoop
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “I ordered this item because my previous bullet ice machine randomly stopped working. I have previously owned 2 other countertop ice machines (bullet ice, pellet/Sonic ice). So, I typically have certain expectations and I am happy to say this machine meets most of them.As with most countertop, the machine arrived with instructions to sit upright for a certain amount of time prior to use. For this particular machine, the settling period was 1 hour. I loved this given that previous machines I had required anywhere from 2 to 12 hrs. So, after unboxing and cleaning the machine I let it set for about 2 hr prior to plugging it up and filling with water. After turning the machine on, the first set of ice was ready in less than 10-12 minutes. This was also a plus, as other machines that I have add seemed to take longer to make ice.Another thing that I was very important to me is that the machine was not loud. And with this machine, I only seem to hear it when it drops the ice. This machine is in my kitchen (2nd level of house), yet I hear the one in my basement and not this one. So, I like that the machine is not overly loud. The quality of the ice is good as well. It produce good thick ice. The machine comes with 2 size options (large or small).The only negatives that I have about the machine is that the water chamber is a bit smaller than my previous machines. Also, the machine comes with a scoop, however there is no suction cup or container to store the scoop. Which information sucks because it have to find something to put the scoop in, if you don’t want to lose or get your scoop dirty from sitting on random surfaces.So far, I definitely recommend this ice machine for its low noise, quick ice production.”
Customer Review: “Fills up in just over an hour! I was actually surprised how quickly this filled up! It’s easy to refill with water, although I wish there was an option to hardline it in, you can ONLY top fill from the basin. I would have given this a five star if it weren’t so LOUD. The fans run constantly when making ice, which is fair because it does put off some heat. I wish they would have found quieter fans. The ice is nice and soft, meeting chewable-ness. It will constantly make fresh ice by allowing the oldest ice the ability to melt back into the basin for easy use. The mechanism is simple and I only had it mess up once, ice had melted or something in a way that let one of the cubes fall back under the arm and the arm had some give in it and it kept working but I resolved it manually to avoid damage. It’s compact, effective and economically priced. Had it not been for the fan noise, I’d be completely happy with a five star.”
5. Grey Magnetic Ice Scoop Holder, Adjustable, Compatible with Ge Opal Nugget Ice Maker 1.0 & 2.0
★★★☆☆ 3.8/5
This magnetic ice scoop holder solves a common problem—keeping your scoop clean and within reach. Designed specifically for GE Opal nugget ice makers, it attaches securely to metal surfaces and adjusts to multiple angles for convenience.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Fits GE Opal Nugget Ice Maker 1.0 & 2.0 models
- ✓ Powerful magnet holds firmly to metal
- ✓ Adjustable angle for easy access
- ✓ Keeps scoop off counters and protected
- ✓ Simple installation—no tools required
Why We Recommend It
If you own a GE Opal and miss having your scoop handy, this holder is a game-changer. It promotes hygiene and organization without adding clutter to your kitchen.
Best For
GE Opal owners who want a tidy, accessible solution for their ice scoop.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Eliminates lost or dirty scoops
- Strong magnet ensures secure attachment
- Adjustable design fits various setups
- Compact and unobtrusive
Cons:
- Only compatible with specific GE models
- Magnetic strength may vary on some surfaces
- Limited functionality beyond scoop storage
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Perfect addition to my GE Opal. No more searching for the scoop or placing it on the counter. Fits perfectly and stays put even when the machine is vibrating.”
Customer Review: “Does what it promises, but the magnet isn’t as strong as I hoped. Still better than leaving the scoop out though.”
6. Nostalgia Snow Pro Electric Slushie Machine, 64 oz Capacity, 4 Reusable Cones, Ice Scoop Included
★★★★☆ 4.3/5
Turn regular ice into fluffy slushies instantly with this electric shaving machine. Perfect for kids’ parties or summer treats, it includes four reusable cones and an ice scoop for hassle-free fun.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Shaves ice into soft, fluffy texture
- ✓ 64 oz hopper holds plenty of ice
- ✓ Includes 4 reusable cones and scoop
- ✓ Compact design saves counter space
- ✓ Kid-safe operation with easy controls
Why We Recommend It
This machine brings retro fun to modern kitchens. Whether you’re making snow cones for a birthday or refreshing drinks on a hot day, it delivers consistent results with minimal effort.
Best For
Families with children, summer gatherings, or anyone who loves nostalgic frozen treats.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Creates soft, chewy slush quickly
- Reusable cones reduce waste
- Easy to assemble and clean
- Fun for all ages
Cons:
- Can jam if too much ice is loaded
- Best used with pre-frozen ice blocks
- Limited to shaving—doesn’t make ice
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “This thing works fantastic, it’s easy to assemble and shaved the snowballs like pro.when you touch the snow feels sooo soft as heck.just because of how good this thing works I rarely even go to snow balls stands N only take a couple of seconds N my snow balls is good to go so yeah the speed is nice on it too.just be careful how much ice you put in there because it can get jam and stop working N check on the inside every once in a while if you plan on shaving alooot of ice because it can jam the shaving part of the machine and stop it for working.but other than that I shaves like pro and worth spending your money on👍❤️”
Customer Review: “This snow cone machine has been a hit in our house! It shaves ice quickly and makes the perfect texture for snow cones. Super easy to operate and clean, even the kids can help. Great for parties, hot summer days, or just a fun treat. We’ve already used it more than we expected—definitely a great buy!”
7. NewAir Portable Ice Maker, 50 lb Daily, 12 Cubes in 7 Mins, 3 Sizes, Kitchen/Office/Bar
★★★★★ 4.9/5
With triple ice size options and a massive 50-pound daily capacity, this NewAir model outperforms many commercial units. It’s engineered for kitchens, offices, and bars needing reliable, scalable ice production.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Produces 12 cubes in just 7 minutes
- ✓ Three ice sizes: small, medium, large
- ✓ Up to 50 pounds of ice per day
- ✓ Energy-efficient and quiet
- ✓ Portable design with sturdy base
Why We Recommend It
This unit strikes an excellent balance between power and practicality. Its three-size settings offer maximum flexibility, and the high daily output suits families or small businesses alike.
Best For
Busy households, entertainment spaces, or remote workstations requiring consistent ice availability.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Fastest production among tested models
- Customizable cube sizes for any drink
- Robust build quality and clear controls
- Handles heavy daily usage effortlessly
Cons:
- Higher initial investment
- Requires cold water input for optimal speed
- Bulkier than entry-level units
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “It was quite at first but got noisy later they should let people know to put cold water in it and it would made ice faster.”
Customer Review: “Excellent build and performance. Makes perfect cubes every time. Only downside is the noise increases after prolonged use, but still acceptable.”
8. Automatic Fast Home Commercial Small Ice Maker, Stainless Steel, Portable Square
★★★★☆ 4.4/5
This automatic ice maker combines home convenience with commercial-grade durability. Featuring stainless steel construction and square ice output, it’s ideal for small businesses or large families needing consistent ice without the complexity of built-in systems.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Automatic operation—no manual intervention needed
- ✓ Stainless steel body resists rust and stains
- ✓ Square ice format cools drinks faster
- ✓ Side air vents ensure proper heat dissipation
- ✓ Compact footprint fits tight spaces
Why We Recommend It
Its automated cycle and robust materials make it a standout for users who want reliability without constant monitoring. The square ice also melts slower than round variants, extending refreshment time.
Best For
Small cafes, home bars, or households with high ice consumption looking for a no-fuss solution.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Fully automatic operation
- Durable stainless steel build
- Square ice melts slowly and cools efficiently
- Space-saving vertical design
Cons:
- Lacks customizable cube sizes
- Initial setup instructions are unclear
- Higher price reflects commercial features
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Great for our café. Makes consistent ice all day without interruption. Easy to clean and maintain.”
Customer Review: “Love the square ice—keeps drinks cold longer. Setup took some trial and error, but worth it.”
9. Ice Maker Replacement Kit, Refrigerator Assembly, Compatible with Kenmore, GE, Frigidaire
★★★★☆ 4.2/5
Extend the life of your refrigerator with this universal ice maker replacement kit. Compatible with major brands like Kenmore, GE, and Frigidaire, it restores lost functionality without replacing the entire appliance.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Compatible with Kenmore, GE, Frigidaire models
- ✓ Includes all necessary mounting hardware
- ✓ Requires only a 1/4″ screwdriver for installation
- ✓ Restores ice production quickly
- ✓ Cost-effective alternative to full replacements
Why We Recommend It
Instead of spending hundreds on a new fridge, this kit offers a simple fix that saves money and reduces waste. Installation is straightforward, and it integrates seamlessly with existing systems.
Best For
Homeowners with aging refrigerators who need functional ice makers without major renovations.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Significantly cheaper than buying new
- Wide brand compatibility
- DIY installation saves labor costs
- Restores full ice functionality
Cons:
- May not fit all model variations
- Quality varies between batches
- No warranty coverage on some units
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “I am so glad I found this part to replace the one in my Frigidaire refrigerator. It is a fraction of the cost of the brand’s replacement and so far works as it should! It was easy to install using a socket wrench and produced ice quickly. No complaints!”
Customer Review: “Would not operate to make any ice & swing arm to shut off would work at all. Sent it back & they’re sending me a replacement. It’s not Amazon it’s the manufacturer!! I’m willing to try one more is it!”
10. Hamilton Beach FlexBrew 5-in-1 Coffee Maker, 12 Cup Drip & Single Serve, Iced Coffee, Black
★★★★☆ 4.0/5
This versatile coffee maker handles everything from drip to single-serve brewing, including iced coffee. With a slim profile and dual-position water reservoir, it maximizes counter space without sacrificing functionality.
Key Features That Stand Out
- ✓ Brews iced or hot coffee
- ✓ Supports both carafe and pod systems
- ✓ Over 40% narrower than standard models
- ✓ Removable 60 oz water reservoir
- ✓ Thermal carafe keeps drinks warm
Why We Recommend It
For multi-tasking kitchens, this brewer eliminates the need for multiple appliances. Its space-saving design and flexible brewing options make it ideal for small homes or shared offices.
Best For
People who want one appliance for hot, cold, single-serve, and carafe brewing needs.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Five-in-one brewing versatility
- Compact design saves space
- Easy-clean components
- Compatible with pods and ground coffee
Cons:
- Pod system can be wasteful
- Iced coffee function requires extra steps
- Plastic parts feel less premium
Customer Reviews
Customer Review: “Saves so much space! Love switching between K-cups and regular coffee. Works great for iced brews too.”
Customer Review: “Wish it had a stronger iced coffee setting, but overall very reliable and easy to use.”
Complete Buying Guide for Side By Side Without Ice Maker
Essential Factors We Consider
When selecting the best side-by-side refrigerator without an ice maker, prioritize energy efficiency, storage layout, and door configuration. Look for models with adjustable shelves, humidity-controlled crispers, and LED lighting. Since you’re avoiding built-in ice makers, ensure the freezer compartment still offers ample space for manual ice trays or occasional bulk freezing.
Budget Planning
Side-by-side refrigerators range from $600 to over $2,500 depending on features like smart technology, stainless finishes, or dual cooling systems. Without ice makers, you’ll save on installation and maintenance costs. Allocate funds wisely—opt for reputable brands with good warranties, and consider seasonal sales or retailer promotions to maximize value.
Final Thoughts
A side-by-side refrigerator without an ice maker gives you freedom, flexibility, and cost savings. Whether you prefer manual ice trays, external dispensers, or dedicated countertop units, today’s market offers solutions tailored to every lifestyle. Focus on capacity, energy ratings, and ease of cleaning to find the perfect match for your home.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I add an ice maker later to my side-by-side fridge?
A: Yes, many manufacturers offer add-on kits that integrate with existing models. However, compatibility varies, so consult your appliance manual or contact the manufacturer before purchasing.
Q: Are side-by-side fridges without ice makers more energy-efficient?
A: Generally yes. Eliminating the ice maker reduces internal load and power consumption. ENERGY STAR-rated models further enhance efficiency, lowering electricity bills over time.
Q: How often should I replace ice trays if I don’t have a built-in maker?
A: Manual ice trays typically last indefinitely if cleaned regularly. Replace only if cracked or warped. Use warm water and mild detergent monthly to prevent mineral buildup.
Q: Do I need special plumbing for a countertop ice maker?
A: Most countertop models are freestanding and use standard water sources via removable reservoirs. Plumbing is optional—just refill as needed unless you opt for a direct-connect version.
Q: Is it worth skipping the ice maker in a new fridge?
A: Absolutely. Without ice makers, you gain counter space, avoid potential repair costs, and enjoy greater flexibility. Pair your fridge with a reliable countertop unit for seamless ice access.
In conclusion, choosing the best side-by-side refrigerator without an ice maker empowers you to customize your kitchen setup while saving money and space. From compact countertop makers to versatile coffee brewers, each product on this list addresses real-world needs with proven performance. Evaluate your household size, usage habits, and aesthetic preferences to make the smartest choice. And remember—whether you’re hosting guests or enjoying a quiet evening, having fresh ice ready at hand makes all the difference. Explore these top-rated options today and elevate your daily routine with convenience and confidence.












